|
|
Post by anapi -season3baby :) on Dec 23, 2013 6:07:34 GMT -5
anapi -season3baby :), I'm not talking about TV shows per se. I'm talking about the concept. There's movies, shows, books, songs talking about it. You name the media vehicle and I'm sure it'll pop something about it. Therefore, overly used.
I'm not totally against the idea. I won't be upset if they use it, but I want to see some originality. At this point I'd take anything but DNA LOL Seriously, if theywill go with Catherine and Vincent are connected cause her mother did something to them with Vincent's blood and hers then what's the point of the epic love story? Then they would be like the pull Tori has over him? Me don't likie that! lol yeah i ll take anything non DNA related - unless they have thougt of a very original way to play the DNA card in which case I will consider  lol, I just want the episode to air ! |
|
|
|
Post by feezya on Dec 23, 2013 6:11:30 GMT -5
I really don't want to see VinCat connected by DNA or some scientific experiment. It would kill the concept of true love to me. Reincarnation is an okay option, but it was already done so many times that just isn't interesting anymore. The only cool thing that pops in my mind that could link Vincat would be if Cat had been a patient of Vincent during his time at Med School. They could had an attraction, but since Cat was a minor and Vincent was engaged, they suppressed those feelings. Then, Vincent went to war and Muirfield messed with his head and he forgot about her while Cat grew up and erased her memories of him with new love interests and her mother's tragic death. i dont watch many tv shows, which other shows have touched on reincarnation? most recently - witches of east end |
|
|
|
Post by pippin on Dec 23, 2013 6:15:08 GMT -5
anapi -season3baby :), I'm not talking about TV shows per se. I'm talking about the concept. There's movies, shows, books, songs talking about it. You name the media vehicle and I'm sure it'll pop something about it. Therefore, overly used.
I'm not totally against the idea. I won't be upset if they use it, but I want to see some originality. What would be your original idea that wouldn't pop up in movies, shows, books, songs, etc? Two people crossing paths previously before getting together has been done before as well. Personally I would prefer that they stay away from supernatural stuff. That VinCat's connection began when he saved her that night her mother was killed and things were more conspiracy centered, but if the show is going down the linked by more than love path then maybe a reincarnation story where VinCat learn that their past attempts at being together always ended with one of them dying, afterall that was true of the Perlman/Hamilton series, then they could be determined to figure out how to try and prevent that. That way the audience wouldn't know whether they were going to get a tragic ending or a happy ending. j |
|
|
|
Post by Naná on Dec 23, 2013 6:34:57 GMT -5
I love this post!  DNA is not romantic! LOL I prefer reincarnation, they have had a history together, and as also wrote, that in their history together, one always have to save the other.  |
|
|
|
Post by feezya on Dec 23, 2013 6:38:50 GMT -5
anapi -season3baby :), I'm not talking about TV shows per se. I'm talking about the concept. There's movies, shows, books, songs talking about it. You name the media vehicle and I'm sure it'll pop something about it. Therefore, overly used.
I'm not totally against the idea. I won't be upset if they use it, but I want to see some originality. What would be your original idea that wouldn't pop up in movies, shows, books, songs, etc? Two people crossing paths previously before getting together has been done before as well. Personally I would prefer that they stay away from supernatural stuff. That VinCat's connection began when he saved her that night her mother was killed and things were more conspiracy centered, but if the show is going down the linked by more than love path then maybe a reincarnation story where VinCat learn that their past attempts at being together always ended with one of them dying, afterall that was true of the Perlman/Hamilton series, then they could be determined to figure out how to try and prevent that. That way the audience wouldn't know whether they were going to get a tragic ending or a happy ending. j I remembered watching the original Batb right till the end, but i have no memory of this. Sign of old age is slowly but surely surfacing  |
|
|
|
Post by anapi -season3baby :) on Dec 23, 2013 6:49:38 GMT -5
What would be your original idea that wouldn't pop up in movies, shows, books, songs, etc? Two people crossing paths previously before getting together has been done before as well. Personally I would prefer that they stay away from supernatural stuff. That VinCat's connection began when he saved her that night her mother was killed and things were more conspiracy centered, but if the show is going down the linked by more than love path then maybe a reincarnation story where VinCat learn that their past attempts at being together always ended with one of them dying, afterall that was true of the Perlman/Hamilton series, then they could be determined to figure out how to try and prevent that. That way the audience wouldn't know whether they were going to get a tragic ending or a happy ending. j I remembered watching the original Batb right till the end, but i have no memory of this. Sign of old age is slowly but surely surfacing yes, even i dont remember it, but i was 10 at the time lol and now nearly 35, tomorrow to be precise |
|
|
|
Post by Naná on Dec 23, 2013 6:50:15 GMT -5
What would be your original idea that wouldn't pop up in movies, shows, books, songs, etc? Two people crossing paths previously before getting together has been done before as well. Personally I would prefer that they stay away from supernatural stuff. That VinCat's connection began when he saved her that night her mother was killed and things were more conspiracy centered, but if the show is going down the linked by more than love path then maybe a reincarnation story where VinCat learn that their past attempts at being together always ended with one of them dying, afterall that was true of the Perlman/Hamilton series, then they could be determined to figure out how to try and prevent that. That way the audience wouldn't know whether they were going to get a tragic ending or a happy ending. j I remembered watching the original Batb right till the end, but i have no memory of this. Sign of old age is slowly but surely surfacing LOL me too! I remenber the Lion (sorry if someone loves him  )...but I can´t remember anything more!  |
|
|
|
Post by anapi -season3baby :) on Dec 23, 2013 6:56:02 GMT -5
I remembered watching the original Batb right till the end, but i have no memory of this. Sign of old age is slowly but surely surfacing LOL me too! I remenber the Lion (sorry if someone loves him )...but I can´t remember anything more! the lion? u mean vincent lol? i was in love with the lion lol - i was really disappointed when i saw what he really looked like No, i do remember the series really well, just can't remember this death destiny thing |
|
|
|
Post by feezya on Dec 23, 2013 6:59:23 GMT -5
I remembered watching the original Batb right till the end, but i have no memory of this. Sign of old age is slowly but surely surfacing yes, even i dont remember it, but i was 10 at the time lol and now nearly 35, tomorrow to be precise Awwwww so you are a christmas present for your parents. Just in case i forget (not relying to much on my memories nowadays  ) have a great b'day, and christmas  |
|
|
|
Post by anapi -season3baby :) on Dec 23, 2013 7:02:49 GMT -5
yes, even i dont remember it, but i was 10 at the time lol and now nearly 35, tomorrow to be precise Awwwww so you are a christmas present for your parents. Just in case i forget (not relying to much on my memories nowadays ) have a great b'day, and christmas thanks! xx |
|
|
|
Post by VinCat❤Destined on Dec 23, 2013 7:05:10 GMT -5
NO they weren't destined to have a tragic ending..I think what pippin meant was that the show runners were going with the original Beauty and The Beast premise or could go there LOL |
|
|
|
Post by Suzieq ❤️ Beastie on Dec 23, 2013 10:18:15 GMT -5
Thanks Pippin for making this Poll. I had made a post and asked about the Mythology in the last Spoiler and Speculation thread before it closed. I was curious why everyone mentioning the "Mythology" but no one clarified what they expected or hoped for specifically. I kept thinking about it.......was it "reincarnation" or organic ........I kept changing my mind. You did a great job in making some categories to think about. However, after thinking about it, in my opinion, ....."Destiny means that you don't have a choice" (Clark in Smallville)...........even though it is said that VinCat are destined,.......I want them above all else CHOOSE EACH OTHER because of what they FEEL! That LOVE grew for each other and not for some predestined reason. In Season 1, I felt like they had a strong connection......but as time went on they GREW to Love each other and it only deepened with all that they went through. Season 2, wiped all that away.......The cast and writers, said that Vincent and Catherine would be shown to really "earn" their love again. We have NOT seen that this season. If they are to "earn" their love, we can't see that they are purely "destined" ..........so which is it? This is where Brad Kern better know what he is doing or it is going to fall flat. You can't say that VinCat will fall in love "all over again" and then show some "Destined Reason"! I think it will be hard to reconcile these two concepts! |
|
|
|
Post by DeadLikeWindsorJulz on Dec 23, 2013 10:28:02 GMT -5
I don't see reincarnation as possible with Mr. Kern at the helm. He seems too obsessed with being "real" with everything - not giving V all his memories back, because that doesn't happen in real life, etc. The science aspect of this show is not in actual practice or reality right now, but it is PLAUSIBLE. Reincarnation is too "out there" to fit into the scientific angle of the show IMO.
Plus, reincarnation kills the whole "free will" to fall in love idea. Like the decision was made for them, not decided by themselves. Pre-determined love just hurts their connection - it isn't personal anymore, just something that "had to happen".
Then again, Kern did say that something along the lines of "the universe wants them to be together". That doesn't seem too romantic to me. Outside circumstances deciding for them - meh.
I am hoping they met somehow during childhood. That gives them a connection without a pre-determined outcome.
|
|
|
|
Post by Laura on Dec 23, 2013 15:29:35 GMT -5
Can I just say I don't like any idea rather than "love" for VinCat to be linked? I just want their attraction (and man! THAT's one hell of a pull  ) to be just out of "love", not supernatural stuff. I mean, if you throw in other factors as "reasons" for why they've fallen for each other, it just brings down those "romance" and "passion" elements, don't you think? There shouldn't be any reason for "falling in love", right? But this is how they've decided to go on with the story line. Maybe I'm wrong, and the love story gets even more romantic. Just gotta wait and see Can it be January 13 already? Please?!  |
|
|
|
Post by ragulr25 on Dec 23, 2013 21:04:12 GMT -5
i m conflicted with both dna and reincarceration.
if it goes under reincarceration it will be like "dracula" tv series
if it is dna the whole epic love goes under the toilet.
i think its gonna be like the movie "adjustment bearau"
|
|
lol, I just want the episode to air !
)...but I can´t remember anything more! 
) have a great b'day, and christmas 
) to be just out of "love", not supernatural stuff. I mean, if you throw in other factors as "reasons" for why they've fallen for each other, it just brings down those "romance" and "passion" elements, don't you think? There shouldn't be any reason for "falling in love", right? 
