Post by pippin on Oct 27, 2015 9:14:36 GMT -5
I didn't mind the story lines of S2 or S3, they were fine for me. While neither season could really compare to S1, I enjoyed S2 and S3 very much. The love triangles in S1 & S2 never really bothered me. In fact, it made VinCat getting together (and back together) that much better. The lack of VinCat passion in S3 is what bothered me most. This is one of the reasons I'm against the VinCat baby story line. I'm afraid it will detract from the romance and passion, and would put VinCat's focus on the baby instead of each other. They need to have that honeymoon period and grow as married couple, not rush to have a child.
If they can bring back the epic VinCat love in S4 and bring closure to their story, I'll be a happy camper. I don't know about a bitter sweet ending, maybe if it's done right, where one sacrifices for the other or something really noble & epic. Still, I don't know if I'd recover. (I've still not recovered from Clark and Lana not ending up together in Smallville.) I think I'd take pippin's rewrite of the "it was a dream" ending over the tragic death of Catherine ending. That one seems just too sad.
Would you be less sad if it was Vincent who died? Personally, I'd pick Catherine over Vincent partially cuz I think we've seen enough of C having to grieve over V so at least it would be different if that was reversed.